Boiled Lobster Dinner

Boiled Lobster Dinner

Menu is subject to seasonal change and availability - to be honest, it fluctuates madly.PLEASE CHECK WITH YOUR SERVER WITH ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. 

Starters, Appetizers & Snacks

Starters, Appetizers & Snacks

Wicked Spicy Crab Cake                       $15

Spicy crab cake with a roasted corn & black bean salad over greens with a side of fresh lemon mayo. Made to order, worth the wait, no whining.  

Fried Calamari                                     $14

Rings & tentacles, if you just want rings you probably don’t really like calamari.

Your choice: With Lemon Garlic Aioli ORTossed in Buffalo sauce with a side of blue cheese

Lobster Rangoon                                  $12

Served with a sweet chili dipping sauce

Beer Cheese & Pretzel                    $7

Beer queso served with a warm pretzel

Nachos                                           $10

Tortillas, fresh jalapeños, black olives, tomatoes, & scallions smothered in stadium-style queso.

Poutine                                               $10

Fries, Cheddar Cheese Curds & Beef Gravy

Try it with your favorite additions, such as Pulled Pork, a fried egg or jalapeños! 

Supernova Scotia                                 $23

Fries, Cheddar Cheese Curds & our own chowder topped with a whopping 6 oz of local fried clams

Add lobster meat to make it a Hypernova Scotia

Corn Dog                                            $4

A state fair staple; meat & sweet on a stick

Fried Pickles                             $9

Maitland Mountain Farms spicy pickle chips fried and crunchy, served with Misery Island Sauce

Chicken Tenders                                   $9

Available tossed Buffalo style, OR with BBQ, Ranch, Misery Island, Honey Mustard or Sweet Chili sauce


Extra Sides:                          $6 each

French Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, Tater Tots, Onion Strings, Pickled Beets , Cole Slaw , Wilted Spinach & Bacon , Black Bean & Corn Salad. 

(Although many of our fried side dishes are gluten free, they are fried in the same fry oil with items that are not.)

Soups  Cup $6  Bowl $8

New England Style Clam Chowder 

Our Signature Chowder is made with fresh chopped local clams, clam juice & our amazing house bacon

Smoky Black Bean & Corn Chili 

Spicy, Vegan & made with Love


Salads 2 sizes; small or entrée

House Salad                    $6 / $9

Caesar Salad                   $6 / $9

Grilled Romaine    Entrée size only      $12

Topped with crumbled bacon & blue cheese

Make your salad a meal!

Add: Steak tips $9.50, Chilled lobster meat $9, Grilled Shrimp $7.50, Grilled Chicken Breast $5.50

Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Citrus-Herb, Blue Cheese, Misery Island, K’s Sriracha Ranch, or Ranch


All Sammiches are served with Maitland Mountain Farms pickles and your choice of fries, tots or slaw.

Pearl Hot Dog                                      $7.50

Pearl makes a mighty fine wiener

Grilled Cheese                                   $7

Choice of Sourdough or Whole Grain

American, Swiss or Pepper Jack

Add Lobster $9, Chicken $5.50, Tomato $1.75

Pulled Pork                                      $14

Topped with spicy BBQ sauce & our own Cole Slaw

Fried Fish Sammich                            $15

Fresh filet of white fish, fried golden brown

Crab Cake Sammich                              $18

Our famous crab cake, made slightly portable

Grilled Chicken Sammich                       $12

Sammich Toppings:

Bacon, $2.75 Cheeses, $1 each: Shredded Mozzarella, American, Swiss, Pepper-Jack, Shredded Cheddar-Jack, or Blue Cheese. Add a Fried Egg, $1. Add sliced Portabella Mushroom $2 Add Pulled Pork, $6 Caramelized Onions or Fresh Jalapenos, 75¢

Lobster Rolls      6 oz. of meat!       $25

Served in a buttered, toasted roll, with fries

Traditional:            (Served chilled)

Sweet lobster meat tossed lightly with our own lemon mayo and diced celery on a bed of lettuce


Connecticut Style:   (Served Warm)

Delicately warmed lobster meat tossed in sweet butter, simple & delicious


Some Say we haveToo Many Lobster Dishes

Boiled Lobster             Market Price

Locally caught, served with drawn butter & lemon

Lobster Mac & Cheese                          $19

Our own three-cheese sauce & elbows mixed with lobster meat, topped with buttery Ritz crumbs

Baked Lobster ‘Pie’                               $25

Succulent lobster meat blended with fresh herbs, wine & butter and topped with Ritz crumbs, served with your choice of fries.

Lobster Rangoon                                 $12

Served with a sweet chili dipping sauce

You can add lobster to any dish             $9

Top your salad with chilled lobster

Top your poutine with warm lobster

On a burger? Yes, please.

We can even super-size your lobster roll if that’s what you need in your life right now.


Fried Seafood Boxes

Each are served with Fries & tartar sauce

Shrimp         6 oz               $16

Calamari       7 oz              $16

Whole Belly Clams   6 oz     $19


Served with your choice of Fries, Tots or Slaw.


Shanty Burger                                     $12

Our Shantastic™ 8 oz. burger

Red Eye Burger                                   $14

Topped with bacon, cheese, a fried egg & K’s Sriracha

Millionaire Burger                                 $18

A burger topped with caramelized onions & a wedge of fried brie.  We replace the lettuce & tomato with wilted spinach & bacon and then drizzle the whole thing with balsamic glaze.

Scary Uncle Sully Burger no substitutions $16

Topped with bacon, Pepper-jack, American, Swiss & fresh jalapenos

Clyde Burger                                        $15

Crusted with Sesame Seeds & Cracked Pepper then topped with blue cheese

Portabella Veggie Burger                  $13

A GFY burger topped with a marinated mushroom cap, grilled & delicious



Boiled Lobster                    Market Price

Locally caught, served with drawn butter & lemon

Mac & Cheese                                      $10

Our three-cheese sauce topped with toasted buttery Ritz crumbs; dress it up: Add Lobster $9 Add Tomato & Spinach $2.75 Add Grilled Chicken $5.50 Add Bacon $2.75 Top with 6 oz fried clams $13

Guinness Marinated Steak Tips          $20

Our famous stout marinated tips, served with wilted spinach & bacon and your choice of fries

Fried Fish & Chips                                $19

Fresh white fish fried golden brown served with house made Cole Slaw and your choice of fries.

Baked Haddock                                    $19

With fresh herbs, wine & butter and topped with Ritz crumbs, served with your choice of fries.

Baked Shrimp                                       $17

Mixed with fresh herbs, wine & butter and topped with Ritz crumbs, served with your choice of fries.


  Follow us!

  We are lobstershantysalem on Instagram

 In the mood for breakfast? 

Visit our sister restaurant The Ugly Mug Diner at 

120 Washington St., Salem - where we serve Breakfast, Brunch & Lunch all day - 7 days a week.



Lobster Roll